Salt Water Taffy Sampler (Try All 80+ Flavors) Try Every Flavor—In One Bag
Not sure where to start? Our Try All Taffy Sampler lets you taste your way through 80+ original Salt Water Taffy flavors—1 piece of each—so you can compare favorites side by side. It’s the easiest way to try the full Taffy Town lineup in one bag, with individually
4.7
113 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Your taffy has become a staple in my household (especially the cherry). Best saltwater taffy by far.
Wish more places did sampler packs like this, Shared it with my coworkers and they loved it.
Will definitely be ordering the customizable bag once we figure out our favorites!
E
Emily · September 24, 2026
Best taffy ever!!
This company makes the best taffy I have ever tasted. It has the PERFECT amount of salt in it, is always fresh and really fun flavors. I just wish the shipping was a little faster (it is torture to wait for delivery :) !!
C
Cheryl · September 21, 2026
This taffy fanatic approves
I am WAY too into taffy. Google told me Shriver's taffy was the best so I ordered some. I was seriously disappointed. Taffy town came up as a top reviewed taffy maker so I went for it. This is some of the most delicious taffy I've ever had. I love the packaging with all the flavors drawn out in the back. It reminded me of jelly bellys or the little miss series
