Caramel Witch

Fat Witch New York

Coffee Witch

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Walnut Baby

(1)

Fat Witch New York

Brownie Mix Original

(1)

$8.50

Fat Witch New York

Pumpkin Caramel Baby

Fat Witch New York

Halloween Baby

Levain Bakery

4.7

(1.2K)

Signature Cookie Assortment - Levain Bakery

Levain Cookie Tin Bundle - Levain Bakery

Caramel squares enrobed in milk and dark chocolate are stacked up together. The squares have a diagonal line of sea salt across the top.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Salted Caramels

(79)

$32.00

Fat Witch New York

Halloween 16 Baby Box

$53.50

Red Velvet NYC

Brownies

(2)

$30.00

saltedbakedgoods

Salted Caramel Brownie

(8)

$6.88

Cast a delicious spell this Halloween with our Enchanting Chocolate Witch! Made from the finest milk or dark chocolate, this delightful witch is here to bring joy and sweetness to your celebrations.

Exclusive offer available

Stage Stop Candy

Enchanting Chocolate Witch

$2.25

Li-Lac Chocolates

Foiled Chocolate Pumpkin (2 oz)

(2)

$8.00

Exclusive offer available

SWITCH ( formerly Scrummy Sweets Co.)

SWITCH® Classic Caramels

(172)

$9.99$10.99

G.O.A.T. Foods

Chocolate Brownie Caramels

(1)

$18.00

Fat Witch New York

Double Chocolate Witch

(3)

Fat Witch New York

Red Baby

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Apple Cinnamon Baby

(3)

Baked by Melissa

4.9

(287)

Fat Witch New York

Witch Ends Fat Witch Original

(1)

$9.00

Fat Witch New York

Classic Cauldron Special

Fat Witch New York

Pumpkin Witch

Li-Lac Chocolates

Walnut Caramel Bars

(40)

Fat Witch New York

Halloween 4 Baby Tin

$20.50

Exclusive offer available

Blissbrew

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 3 Dozen (72 Ounce)

$174.99

Exclusive offer available

Café Cravings

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 3 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$136.47

Exclusive offer available

Hearthstone Café

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 3 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$111.98

Uncle Butch's Fudge

4.7

(22.2K)

universal flavours

WF Caramel Butter SC

$5.00

Exclusive offer available

SWITCH ( formerly Scrummy Sweets Co.)

SWITCH® Salted Caramels

(100)

$9.99$10.99

Minnie Beasley’s

4.6

(5.5K)

Fat Witch New York

Almond Baby

(3)

Fat Witch New York

Caramel Baby

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Fat Witch Baby

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Brownie Bites

$5.00

Fat Witch New York

9 Baby All Star

$32.50

Fat Witch New York

4 Baby Gift Tin

$19.50

Li-Lac Chocolates

Big Scary Chocolate Ghost

(3)

$75.00

Fat Witch New York

Tiny Bag B&W

$9.50

Recchiuti Confections

4.8

(1.8K)

Exclusive offer available

Hearthstone Café

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 4 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$135.98

Li-Lac Chocolates

Halloween Pumpkin Pop

(9)

$7.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

Butter Crunch

(120)

$23.00

Exclusive offer available

NY Spice Shop

Dark Chocolate Pumpkin Spice Caramels

$19.99

Silverland Bakery

Chocolate Caramel

$25.95

Fat Witch New York

Snow Witch

(4)

Halloween candy haul

Chocolate minis, gummies, lollipops, and hard candy.

Fat Witch New York

Snow Baby

(2)

Li-Lac Chocolates

Big Chocolate Witch

(5)

$42.00

Fat Witch New York

Peanut Butter Baby

Fat Witch New York

Halloween Witchy Tiny Bags

$64.50

Fat Witch New York

5 Pack Fat Witch Coffee

$9.00

Flat, round disks of mint and raspberry soft cream are enrobed in dark chocolate. Several of the patties have been broken in half, reveling white mint cream centers and pink raspberry cream centers.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Cream Patties

(24)

Extra-fudgy caramel swirl brownies with rich chocolate

Ruth's Brownie Kitchen

Caramel Swirl Extra Fudgy

$44.99

Exclusive offer available

Blissbrew

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 4 Dozen (48 Ounce)

$211.99

Olive My Pickle

4.6

(37.1K)

LiveBrine Probiotic Pickle Juice: Classic Kosher Dill

Li-Lac Chocolates

Big Chocolate Pumpkin

(12)

$65.00

Exclusive offer available

Café Cravings

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 2 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$107.24

67% off

Sheboygan Discount Warehouse

Salted Caramel Brownie Brittle 1oz

$0.39$1.19

ScuttleButter Bakery

Brownies with Salted Caramel

$4.50

Fat Witch New York

Fat Witch

(3)

Fat Witch New York

Sesame Baby

(1)

Fat Witch New York

Yuzu Baby

Li-Lac Chocolates

Chocolate Witch (Hazel & Jack)

$15.00

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Fat Witch New York

Build A Witch At Home

$30.50

Li-Lac Chocolates

Caramel Bars

(14)

Fat Witch New York

Witchy Tiny Bags

$63.50

Exclusive offer available

Stage Stop Candy

Chocolate Witch

(1)

$2.50

Twisted Cookie

Salted Caramel Brownie

$7.99

Exclusive offer available

Café Cravings

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 4 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$165.72

Li-Lac Chocolates

8-pc Halloween Box

(7)

$28.00

Exclusive offer available

Hearthstone Café

Ruth’s Caramel Swirl Cake Style Brownies 2 Dozen – Gourmet Baked Treats | Delicious Gift with The Finest Ingredients | Guaranteed to Arrive Fresh

$87.98

BonBon - A Swedish Candy Co

4.3

(5.7K)

Sir Walter Candy Co.

Wrapped Caramels

(3)

$2.10

Fat Witch New York

Blonde Witch

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Double Chocolate Baby

(1)

Fat Witch New York

Matcha Baby

(1)

Fat Witch New York

Blonde Baby

(2)

Fat Witch New York

Big Witch Box

$43.50

Fat Witch New York

Halloween Cauldron