Shadow Candle

Was expecting a more feminine smell, but still pleasant

Was expecting and would have preferred a more feminine smell, based on the artwork, but my wife and I both agree it is decidedly more masculine and not extremely fall-like. It's still pleasant and I'll be using it this Halloween season. Really, I'd give it a 3.5 if I could.

Too much tobacco

Firewood smoke that reminds us of fall and winter is great, but this reminds me too much of cigarette/pipe/cigar smoke. Not very pleasant for me, but someone else may have a very different perspective.

Mysterious

This candle is everything you would expect from its name. Shadow is sexy, mysterious, and masculine. The smoky and musk sense blend perfectly with hints of sandalwood.