Handmade Witch Pia Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Skater Pia Pin

A circular enamel pin with a salmon border and waves in the background with the words "Sea Witch" on it. It has a potion bottle, a scallop and conch shell on it.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Sea Witch Enamel Pin

Magical by Marissa

Movie Poster Pin

A circular hard enamel pin with rose gold metal. There is a mint green border around a pastel pink circle in the background. The bottom of the pin has bubble letters in purple that read "Basic Witch" above this there is a black cauldron with yellow moon phases full of bubbles. There is a broom above this and a black pointed hat to the right of the broom. Sparkles are around all of the objects.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Basic Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Higurashi Hanyuu Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Darkstalkers Morrigan Pin

A pin shaped like a black witch's hat with gold accents and a small branch of leaves sits on a black background

The Quirky Cup Collective

Witches Hat Enamel Pin - Black

(10)

BotTwins

Digital Circus Badges

(1)

$13.00

Pin & Tonic

Witch's Cat Enamel Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade BG3 Raphael Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade MCR Frank Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade CRK Custard Cookie III Pin

30% off

KirasElixir

Small Witches - hard enamel pin

$15.51$22.16

Real Sic

Medusa Enamel Pin - Greek Mythology Feminist Witch Lapel Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Beastform Pia Pin

Magical by Marissa

Phoenix Pin

(1)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Witch Beri Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Skater Slime Pia Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Tears For Things Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Deltarune Kris Pin

A Stitch in Time

Witchy Pin Set by Puntini Puntini

BotTwins

Drifloon Handmade Pin

$11.00

A circular enamel pin with a blue border, navy background, and maroon words that say "Lazy Witch". It has a vintage TV, bag of chips, a yellow couch and a black cat on the couch.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Lazy Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Higurashi Shion Pin

Exclusive offer available

Sunflowerly

Witch Hat - Personalized Witch Pin

$22.95

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade SH2 That Dog Pin

Jaizure

Celestial Witch

(1)

$18.00

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Chang'e Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade FFXIV Estinien Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Pia Play Pin

Magical by Marissa

Sitting Pin

(3)

thatskyshop

Mischief Witch Hat Pin

$42.00

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade BeriBug Sleeping Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Infinity Nikki Normal Outfit Pin

Bird Ov Prey

Witching Hour Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Higurashi Rena Pin

The Quirky Cup Collective

Witches Hat Enamel Pin - Green

(16)

Magical by Marissa

Pop Culture pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade MCR Ray Pin

BotTwins

Hazbin Hotel Badges | Angel Dust + Lucifer + Alastor + Sir Pentious

(5)

$5.00

A circular enamel pin. It has a yellow border with a light blue background and hot pink letters that read "Craft Witch". It has a needle, embroidery floss, a purple yarn ball and scissors depicted on it.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Craft Witch Enamel Pin

(2)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Darkstalkers Felicia Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Resin Lapel Pin

Studio Pins and Paper

Peas 🫛 1.4 inch

€12.50

Medusa Gothic

Witch Enamel Pins

$12.99

Walter Bauman Jewelers

Estate Pandora SS Mottled Glass Bead Charm

$20.00

Two Photon

Spooky Nightshade Witch Enamel Pin

$15.00

thatskyshop

Mischief Witch Hat Pin

$29.00

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Stellar Bear Studios Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Elegg: Shock and Boom NIKKE Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade BG3 Gale Pin

TheBunBunShop

Artsy Witch Bun | Enamel Pin

(3)

$21.65

100% Soft

Scarlet Witch Enamel Pin

(9)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Digibaby Botamon Pin

War and Peas Shop

Magic Witch Enamel Pin

Myuna Art

Myuna's Little Witch Acatemia Witch Familiar Pins, Cute pin, Cute Witchy Animal Hard Enamel Pins

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Umamusume Vodka Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Umamusume Daiwa Scarlet Charm

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade BG3 Halsin Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Umineko Maria Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Darkstalkers Lilith Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Confused Pia Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Pia in a Box Pin

magicalbornsisters

Pink Witch Key Pin

$13.00

BotTwins

Hazbin Hotel - Angel Dust - Hard Enamel Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Umineko Shannon Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Long Yang Pin

magicalbornsisters

Fire Whiskey Pin

Enamel pins of two witches with mint hair riding brooms.

Love Pain and Stitches

Strange Witch Pin

(5)

bcv.glass

MC Bicone Xilion Cut beads High Sparkle 4 mm, Cobalt (30050), Bohemia Crystal Glass, Czechia 45169302

$1.75

Enamel Pins

Bewitched Samantha Pin

$9.99

BotTwins

Derpy Tiger Handmade Pin

$11.00

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Infinity Nikki Grooming Outfit Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Beastform Pia Charm

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Pia Slime Pin

BotTwins

Helluva Boss - Fizz - Hard Enamel Pin

(2)

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Uma Pia Pin

Jewelry Brands Shop

Marvel WandaVision Scarlet Witch 3D Cast Tiara Pin

BotTwins

Helluva Boss - Blitz - Hard Enamel Pin

100% Soft

Wiccan Enamel Pin

(13)

Retrophiliac

Witchy Sparkle Glow-in-the-Dark Pin

$11.00

BotTwins

Hazbin Hotel - Husk - Hard Enamel Pin

BotTwins

Helluva Boss - Oz - Hard Enamel Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade DunMeshi Farcille Pin

Stellar Bear Studios

Handmade Umamusume Rice Shower Charm

BotTwins

Genshin Impact Tighnari - Hard Enamel Pin

Pole Dancing Pins

Witch (Light Skin) Enamel Pin