Drinking Chocolate Kit

Karma Sauce

4.9

(127)

Ghost Island hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Burn After Eating hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce

(12)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Habanero Lime Switchback Craft Beer Hot Sauce

(10)

NewEngland.com Store

Caramel Apple Kit

$23.95

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Chocolate Peppermint Snaps

(4)

$7.00

myspicebuds

4.9

(56)

A bottle of My Spice Buds Super Mirchi vinegar-free hot sauce on a white background, featuring a yellow label and a black cap, with a Scovie 2026 1st in Place award badge overlay.

A bottle of My Spice Buds Tangy Mirch Sweet & Hot Sauce with a gold cap, featuring a green 'International Flavor Awards' badge overlay on the upper left, set against a plain white background.

Bottle of My Spice Buds Mango Mirchi hot sauce on a white background

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mustard Lover's Gift Box

$64.00

Castle Kitchen Natural Hot Chocolate Mix Variety Pack - Dairy-Free, Vegan Complete Mixes - Just Add

Exclusive offer available

Brew & Bite

Castle Kitchen Natural Hot Chocolate Mix Variety Pack - Dairy-Free, Vegan Complete Mixes - Just Add Water - Pack of 2 (Classic Caramel Dark Chocolate & Double Dutch Dark Chocolate) 14 oz Each

$72.38

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler

(4)

$34.99

HEATONIST

4.7

(22.7K)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Salted Bourbon Caramel

(5)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard

(7)

8% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Pride Pack 🌈

(3)

$35.00$38.00

Taza Chocolate Organic 40% Dark Shaved Hot Chocolate Mix, 8 oz Bag

6% off

Fresh Kart USA

Taza Chocolate Organic 40% Dark Shaved Hot Chocolate Mix, 8 oz Bag

$16.03$17.02

Shade Time Artisan Hot Sauce

4.8

(4)

"Bottle of Caribbean Scorch hot sauce with curry spices and chiles"

"Mango Blaze hot sauce bottle with mangoes and habanero peppers"

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

Budget Friendly Box

$31.16$36.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Heady Topper Hot Sauce

(7)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Ooh La La - A Guster Hot Sauce

(3)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Ghost Verde Pickle Genersaucity Hot Sauce

(7)

Rancho Gordo

(2.4K)

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

Garlic Cilantro Jalapeno

(116)

$7.79$9.00

7% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mustard Lovers Bundle

$51.00$55.00

Fishwife

4.8

(13.6K)

Murder Hornet Hot Sauce

4.8

(263)

7% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Teetotaler Hot Sauce Set

$41.00$44.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

The Original Caramel

(12)

7% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Ultimate Farm to Fork Set

$82.75$88.98

Harmacy Hot Sauce Co.

4.9

(1K)

Harmacy Hot Sauce Co. 'Buffalo Soldier' sauce jar with pineapple, lime, and spices on a white background

Jar of Harmacy Hot Sauce Co. 'Smoke Signal' pepper sauce with apricot slices and a bottle of maple syrup on a white background.

Hot sauce jar with 'Harmacy Hot Sauce Co.' label surrounded by citrus fruits and herbs on a white background

Jar of Harmacy Hot Sauce Co. Totec's Tears with plums, chili peppers, and a chili pepper on a white background

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Vermont Maple Caramel

(4)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

(20)

Exclusive offer available

Newks Sauces

Groovy Green (Apple + Jalapeño)

(3)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Gustard - A Guster Mustard

(8)

Burlap & Barrel

4.9

(13.9K)

Jar of Purple Stripe Garlic from Burlap & Barrel on a beige background

Jar of Burlap & Barrel Toasted Pepita Pumpkin Spice on a brown textured background

Smoked Pimenton Paprika from Burlap & Barrel

Bag of Mighty Tasty Granola and three jars of Fat Toad Farm caramel on a wooden surface with a gray background.

10% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Parfait Partners Set

$29.00$32.06

Exclusive offer available

Newks Sauces

Big Bottle (10 oz) Three Pack

(3)

$60.00

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

Co-Conspirator

(127)

$9.79$12.00

7% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Savory Sensation Bundle

(2)

$82.00$88.00

Fat Toad Farm Full Line of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauces

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

The Top Flight

(1)

$120.00

10% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cozy Tea Set

$36.00$39.98

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mulled Cider Caramel

(1)

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

GoS Mustard

(78)

$9.79$12.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract

(2)

$20.00

TorchBearer Sauces

4.8

(1.1K)

Smokey Horseradish Sauce - TorchBearer Sauces

Nekrogoblikon's Pickled Goblin dill pickle hot sauce bottle

Mixed 12oz Sauce Case of 12 - TorchBearer Sauces

July Bundle by Bloody Disgusting - TorchBearer Sauces

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Scape Sauce

(8)

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

Scotch Bonnet Mango

(87)

$7.79$9.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Smoked Serrano Squash Reaper X Hot Sauce

(3)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Vanilla Bean Caramel

(7)

Heat

4.7

(899)

Exclusive offer available

Newks Sauces

All 10 Flavors

$95.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cookies and Caramel Gift Box

$49.00

Exclusive offer available

Matilda Co

Taza Chocolate Organic Oat Milk Chocolate Bar, Coffee Toffee, 2.5 Ounce (10 Count), Vegan

$41.67

Cozy fall breakfast

Granola, oat cups, and nut butter.

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel

(3)

Halloween candy haul

Chocolate minis, gummies, lollipops, and hard candy.

6% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet and Savory Gift Set

(1)

$62.00$66.28

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Spice Snaps

(4)

$7.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cinnamon Caramel

(2)

Exclusive offer available

High Desert Sauce Co

After Dark Adobo

(67)

$4.50$12.00

Captain Mowatt's

4.9

(2.9K)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cold Brew Coffee Caramel

(4)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce

(6)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Claire's Maple Reserve Goat's Milk Caramel

$11.99

Snake River Farms

4.6

(15.6K)

raw SRF Black® tomahawk steak |SRF Black®

Bag of Snake River Farms kettle chips cooked in Wagyu beef tallow on a light gray background

Two hot sauce bottles and three caramel jars in a box with wood shavings

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Heat Gift Box

$72.00

A picture of Organic Winter Warmer Chocolate Sampler 8 Count in packaging on a white background

The Chocolate Dispensary

Winter Warmer Sampler

$32.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Flight of Petit Caramels

(1)

$50.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

DIY Caramel Apple Kit

$23.49

Fat Toad Farm Sweet Duo Original & Salted Bourbon

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box

(1)

$34.99

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Raspberry Almond Cookies

(3)

$6.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce

(27)

Exclusive offer available

Newks Sauces

Oregon Zoo Fundraiser Hot Sauce!

(4)