Four ingredients to rule them all: Peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels. Plus one not-so-secret ingredient — honey — which gives our peanut butter ice cream a dreamy, nougat-y texture and flavor. Think of eating this flavor like digging for buried treasure. There's something fun to be found in every single bite!
Heads up: we’re in
4.6
320 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
2 scoops is all you need
This super premium ice cream has everything for the chocolate and peanut butter lover. Very rich and decadent. You don’t need much to satisfy your urge for a special dessert.
D
DAVID · September 24, 2026
Like a Take 5 Candy Bar, but Better
The flavor combo is familiar and fantastic. The salty and sweet ingredients hit all the right notes that you'd get from a candy bar made with similar ingredients, but the creamy ice cream takes this treat to the next level.
A
Adam · August 19, 2026
love love love this flavor...waiting to try cherry vanilla w/chocolate covered waffle cone pieces