We’ve taken steps to make Jonathan's Favorite with more natural ingredients. The colors may look a little less vibrant now, but the taste is just as good — if not better!
Discover the licorice that’s earned a special place in the heart of one of our founders. Jonathan’s Favorite combines the bold, chewy goodness of classic black licoric
4.5
2K ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Better than the commercial “Good-n-Plenty” brand of black licorice by 100 times! Very savory and sweet from the candy coating. Easy access from the round package container.
Keifster68 · September 12, 2026
I love it. I have been looking everywhere for these. I need to order more. Maybe make it with pastel colors. Just a thought.
A
Audrey · 18 days ago
Happy Wife!
This is a new favorite for my wife! A great summer solution for her black licorice fix that doesn't melt in our Arizona heat.